Start with the problem, not the tool. Teams that buy tools because they look impressive often end up with overlapping subscriptions and little change in how work gets done. Teams that start with a clear job to be done choose better and measure results. The Academy's glossary explains scheduling tool and API.
Define the job
Write one sentence describing the task the tool should help with, how long it takes now and what good output looks like. For example: Turn our monthly webinar into ten short vertical clips with accurate captions, currently taking six hours.
The evaluation checklist
| Area | Questions to ask |
|---|---|
| Output quality | Are results good enough with light editing? |
| Time saved | How much faster is the task end to end? |
| Ease of use | Can the team use it without lengthy training? |
| Data protection | Where is data stored, and is it used for training? |
| Rights | Can outputs be used commercially? |
| Integrations | Does it connect with tools you already use? |
| Cost | What is the real cost per user and per month? |
| Reliability | Is the company established and the tool stable? |
| Support | Is help available when things go wrong? |
Test with your real content
Demos use ideal examples. Test tools with your own footage, captions, data and brand guidelines. Run the same task through two or three tools and compare results side by side.
Data protection and security
Read the privacy policy and terms. Check whether inputs are used to train models, where data is stored, whether the tool offers business agreements and how access is managed. Avoid tools that cannot answer these questions clearly. The Academy's guide to an AI policy for marketing teams covers data rules.
Commercial rights
Check that outputs can be used commercially and whether there are restrictions, such as watermarks on free plans or limits on advertising use. For images and music, rights terms are especially important.
Integrations
Tools that connect to your scheduling platform, design tools, cloud storage or social accounts save time. Check whether integrations use official platform APIs, because unofficial methods can put accounts at risk.
Cost
Compare cost per user, usage limits and what happens when you exceed them. Many tools charge per seat, per credit or per minute of video. Calculate the cost against time saved. The Academy's guide to the social media tool stack for small business shows how to keep costs down.
Overlap
Before adding a new tool, check whether tools you already pay for offer similar features. Many design, scheduling and editing platforms now include AI features.
Running a trial
- Choose one task and two or three tools.
- Define success measures, such as time saved and quality.
- Test for two to four weeks with real work.
- Gather feedback from everyone who used it.
- Decide, then document how the tool will be used.
Accuracy
For tools that produce text, check facts carefully. AI tools often quote outdated platform specifications. TikTok's maximum video length, for instance, is currently 10 minutes (60 minutes for some accounts); sweet spot 21–34 seconds✓, and a tool trained on older data may get this wrong.
Accessibility
Check whether the tool supports accessibility, such as accurate captions, alt text suggestions and readable outputs, and whether the tool itself is accessible for team members.
Vendor stability
The AI market moves fast, and some tools close or change pricing suddenly. Prefer tools from established companies for core workflows, keep exports of your work and avoid locking critical processes into a single small vendor without a backup plan.
Reviewing tools regularly
Review your AI tools every six months. Cancel tools that are rarely used, check whether new features in existing tools make others redundant and revisit tools you rejected, since quality improves quickly.
Involving the team
The people who will use a tool every day should help choose it. Ask them to test it on real tasks and share honest feedback on quality and ease of use. A tool that a manager likes but the team avoids delivers nothing. Agree who owns each tool, including billing, access and training.
Free versus paid plans
Free plans are useful for testing, but often carry limits on usage, watermarks or weaker data terms.
Asking vendors the right questions
Ask vendors directly about data retention, model training, security certifications and how they handle deletion requests. Clear, written answers are a good sign.
Documenting decisions
Record which tools you evaluated, the results of trials and why you chose or rejected each one. Documentation helps when budgets are reviewed, when new team members ask why a tool is used and when you revisit decisions as tools improve.
A worked example
A charity's social team is offered five AI video tools. It defines the job as captioning and clipping event recordings, tests three tools on the same recording, compares caption accuracy and time taken and checks data terms. One tool is clearly better for its footage and integrates with its scheduling platform. The team runs a month's trial, confirms the time savings and subscribes.
Common mistakes
- Choosing tools before defining the job.
- Testing only with demo content.
- Ignoring data and rights terms.
- Paying for overlapping tools.
- Never reviewing subscriptions.
Learning to choose tools
The Academy's AI tools module in the second level covers choosing and using AI tools, and the AI and automation at scale module in the leader level covers building tool stacks for teams. The free assessment shows where you would start.
