After a crisis, people are tired and want to move on. Skipping the review means losing valuable lessons. The best time to hold a post mortem is within a week or two of the crisis ending, while memories are fresh but emotions have calmed.
Principles
- Blame-free: focus on systems and decisions, not individuals.
- Evidence-based: use logs, screenshots and data.
- Honest: acknowledge what went wrong as well as right.
- Action-focused: end with clear changes and owners.
Who should take part
Include everyone involved: the crisis lead, social media team, customer service, specialists such as legal or operations, and leaders who approved statements. In a small business, this may be two or three people.
The review structure
| Section | Questions |
|---|---|
| Timeline | What happened, and when? |
| Detection | How and when did we first notice? Could we have noticed sooner? |
| Escalation | Did the right people get involved quickly? |
| Response | Were statements timely, accurate and consistent? |
| Channels | Which platforms mattered most? |
| Impact | Effect on customers, sentiment, sales and reputation |
| What worked | Actions to keep |
| What did not | Actions to change |
| Root causes | Why did it happen in the first place? |
| Actions | Changes with owners and deadlines |
Building the timeline
Reconstruct the incident minute by minute where possible, using screenshots, message logs and notification times. Note when the first warning signs appeared, when the team became aware, when key decisions were made and when statements went out. Timelines often reveal delays nobody noticed at the time.
Measuring impact
Look at volume of mentions, sentiment, reach of critical posts, customer service contacts, sales and any media coverage. Compare with normal levels before the crisis and track recovery afterwards. The Academy's guide to sentiment analysis explains how to measure tone.
Finding root causes
Ask why the crisis happened, then ask why again until you reach underlying causes. A viral complaint about a faulty product might trace back to a supplier change, a missed quality check and no process for customer feedback reaching the product team. Fixing root causes prevents repeats.
Reviewing the response
- Was the issue detected early enough?
- Did escalation reach the right people quickly?
- Were holding statements ready and approved fast?
- Were scheduled posts and ads paused?
- Were messages consistent across channels?
- Were staff and customer service briefed?
- Did updates come when promised?
- Was the team supported?
Turning findings into actions
Each lesson should become a specific action with an owner and a deadline, such as add a template for product recalls by the end of the month, or set up alerts for brand mentions on TikTok. Track actions until they are complete.
Updating the crisis plan
Update the crisis plan, escalation matrix, holding statement templates and contact lists based on what you learned. The Academy's guide to a social media crisis plan explains each part.
Sharing lessons
Share a short summary with the wider team, focusing on what changes as a result. This builds confidence that lessons are acted on and helps everyone respond better next time.
Platform lessons
Note which platforms drove the crisis and how they behaved. On TikTok, videos can reach people far beyond followers; TikTok's documented signals are completion rate and rewatches, shares, comments, likes, interest signals from watch behaviour✓. On X, journalists may pick up stories quickly. Lessons about platform dynamics help prioritise monitoring next time.
A worked example
A café chain faces a viral video showing a hygiene problem. After the crisis settles, the team holds a post mortem. The timeline shows the video circulated for three hours before anyone noticed, because nobody monitored TikTok mentions. The holding statement was strong, but promotional posts kept running for an hour. Root causes include a cleaning rota gap at one site. Actions include setting up TikTok monitoring, adding pausing posts to the first-hour checklist and introducing a new cleaning audit. The plan is updated and shared with all managers.
When to hold a post mortem
Hold one after every crisis and after any serious issue that came close. Short reviews for near misses often prevent bigger problems later.
Running the meeting
Set aside an hour or two and share the timeline and data in advance so people arrive prepared. A neutral facilitator, ideally someone not closely involved in the response, keeps discussion focused and fair. Start with what went well, which helps people speak openly, then move through each section of the review structure. Capture actions as you go and agree owners before the meeting ends.
Customer follow-up
Part of recovery is going back to people who were affected. Check that complaints were resolved, that promised refunds or replacements arrived and that anyone who was harmed has been supported. A personal follow-up message weeks later can turn a damaged relationship into a loyal one, and it often reveals lessons that internal data misses.
Tracking recovery
Keep measuring sentiment, mentions, customer contacts and sales for several weeks after the crisis. Recovery is rarely instant, and tracking it shows whether actions are working and when normal activity can fully resume.
Common mistakes
- Skipping the review because everyone is tired.
- Blaming individuals instead of fixing systems.
- No timeline, so delays are missed.
- Lessons with no owners or deadlines.
- Never updating the crisis plan.
Learning to review crises
The Academy's crisis management module in the leader level covers post mortems, recovery and updating crisis plans, and the team and governance module covers processes and approvals. The free assessment shows where you would start.
