A well-designed test makes hiring decisions clearer and gives candidates a chance to show what they can do. A poorly designed one wastes everyone's time, favours people with free evenings and can look like a way to get free work. The goal is a short, relevant, fair exercise that predicts how someone will perform in the role.
What to test
| Skill | Possible test |
|---|---|
| Writing | Rewrite three captions for different platforms |
| Strategy | Outline a one-month plan for a scenario |
| Community | Draft replies to five tricky comments |
| Measurement | Interpret a sample report and recommend actions |
| Judgement | Decide what to do in a sensitive scenario |
| UK rules | Spot problems in a sample influencer post |
| Video | Script or storyboard a short video |
Choose the two or three skills that matter most for the role rather than testing everything.
How to test social media candidates proportionately
Keep take-home tasks to around two hours at most, and say so clearly. For senior roles or longer tasks, consider paying candidates for their time. Avoid tasks that look like real work you will use, such as a full campaign for your next launch. Use a fictional or past scenario instead.
Example tasks
Audit: give candidates a sample account and ask for three observations and three recommendations. This shows analytical thinking and prioritisation.
Content: provide a short brief and ask for posts on two platforms. Platform knowledge matters; for example, the LinkedIn post limit is 3,000 characters (first ~210 show before 'see more')✓, so strong candidates will consider how much shows before the "see more" cut-off.
Community: share five sample comments, including a complaint, a troll, a question, a compliment and a potential crisis signal. Ask for replies and what they would escalate.
Reporting: provide a page of anonymised metrics and ask what they would tell a manager and what they would change.
Scenario questions in interview
- A post is getting angry comments about something unrelated in the news. What do you do?
- An influencer partner posts without the ad label. How do you handle it?
- Your best-performing format suddenly drops in reach. How do you investigate?
- A senior colleague wants to post something you think is risky. What do you say?
Listen for structured thinking, calm judgement and awareness of rules.
Scoring rubrics
Agree criteria and a scoring scale before reviewing any work. For each skill, describe what weak, good and excellent look like. Have at least two people score independently, then compare. Rubrics make decisions fairer and easier to explain to candidates.
Avoiding bias
Remove names and identifying details from submitted tasks where possible. Do not over-reward polished design if design is not part of the role. Recognise transferable skills from career changers, such as customer service or journalism. Offer reasonable adjustments for candidates who need them. The Academy's guide to social media training for career changers explains how career changers often build relevant skills.
Using structured assessments
Standardised assessments can complement practical tasks by giving a consistent view of knowledge across areas. The Academy's free assessment places people across six areas in about five minutes. Use any assessment as one input among several, not a pass or fail gate.
Giving feedback
Candidates invest time in tasks. Give brief, specific feedback to those who complete them, especially finalists. Good feedback reflects well on your organisation and helps candidates improve.
Red flags in test responses
- Suggesting buying followers or using engagement pods.
- Ignoring disclosure rules for partnerships.
- Arguing with commenters rather than de-escalating.
- Recommendations unconnected to goals.
- Copying generic content without adaptation.
Testing for ethics and compliance awareness
Include at least one scenario that tests awareness of UK rules and ethical judgement. Show a sample influencer post without a clear ad label, a competition post with no terms or a reply that shares a customer's personal details in public, and ask what is wrong. Strong candidates spot the issue quickly, explain why it matters and suggest a practical fix. Candidates who miss obvious problems may need significant training before they can be trusted to post unsupervised. The Academy's guide to the social media compliance checklist lists the areas worth testing.
Live versus take-home tasks
Live tasks, completed during the interview, reveal how someone thinks under time pressure and avoid concerns about outside help. Take-home tasks give candidates time to show their best work and suit people who find interviews stressful. Many teams use a short take-home task followed by a live discussion of the submission, which combines the strengths of both and lets you probe the reasoning behind each choice.
Testing for learning ability
Social media changes so quickly that the ability to learn matters as much as current knowledge. Ask candidates how they stay current, what they learned recently and how they adapted to a platform change. A short follow-up question about how they would research something they do not know reveals a lot.
Bringing it together
Combine the portfolio, interview, practical task and references. Weigh evidence across all four rather than relying on any single strong or weak moment. The Academy's guide on how to hire a social media manager covers the full process, and the guide to social media manager interview questions offers more prompts.
After the hire
The test results are useful beyond the hiring decision. Share strengths and gaps with the new starter and use them to shape their development plan. The Academy's guide to onboarding a social media manager explains how to build on them in the first 90 days.
