A good social media manager can transform how an organisation is seen, while a poor hire can damage reputation, waste budget and leave the team picking up the pieces. The process below helps you find someone with the right mix of creativity, judgement, analytical skill and knowledge of the rules.
Define what you actually need
Start with the work, not the job title. List the platforms, the volume of content, whether the role includes paid social, community management, video production, reporting or managing agencies. Decide which skills are essential and which can be learned. The Academy's guide to the social media manager job description provides a template.
Essential skills to look for
| Skill | What good looks like |
|---|---|
| Strategy | Links content to business goals and audiences |
| Content | Writes well, understands formats and briefs creative |
| Video | Plans and edits short-form video, or manages those who do |
| Community | Handles comments and complaints calmly and quickly |
| Measurement | Chooses meaningful metrics and explains results |
| Paid social | Understands campaign basics, even if not a specialist |
| UK rules | Knows ad disclosure, data protection and consumer law basics |
| Judgement | Recognises sensitive moments and escalates appropriately |
The Academy's guide to social media manager skills goes deeper.
Writing the advert
Be specific about the platforms, the audience, the scale and what success looks like after six months. Include the salary range, which attracts more applicants and saves time. Mention how the role fits into the team and who it reports to. Avoid lists of every possible skill; focus on what matters most.
Where to find candidates
- LinkedIn and general job boards.
- Specialist marketing and creative job boards.
- Recommendations from your network and agencies.
- Freelancers who have worked with you.
- Career changers with transferable skills, such as journalism, customer service or retail.
The Academy's guide to social media training for career changers explains how career changers build relevant skills.
Looking past follower counts
A large personal following shows the ability to build an audience for oneself, which is not the same as running a brand account. Ask about brand accounts they have managed, the goals, the results and what they would do differently. Look for evidence of strategic thinking, not just creativity.
Portfolio review
Ask candidates to share examples of work: posts, campaigns, reports and any content plans. Ask what their role was, what the brief was and what the results were. Be wary of portfolios showing only polished outputs with no explanation of process or outcomes.
Practical tasks
A short, paid or reasonably scoped task reveals real ability. Examples include auditing your current social presence, drafting a week of content for a scenario or responding to a set of tricky comments. Keep tasks proportionate. The Academy's guide on how to test social media candidates has detailed examples.
Interview questions
Ask about real situations: a post that went wrong, a campaign that underperformed, how they handled a complaint, how they decide what to measure. Include questions on UK rules, such as how they label paid partnerships. The Academy's guide to social media manager interview questions offers more.
Testing platform knowledge
Ask practical questions about the platforms you use most. What length suits a LinkedIn post that is designed to start conversations? How would they plan a short-form video series, given that the maximum Instagram Reel length is 3 minutes (up to 20 minutes for some accounts via uploads)✓? How do they decide between a Reel and a carousel? Good candidates explain trade-offs rather than reciting rules, and they know where to check current figures rather than relying on memory.
Red flags
- Promises of fast follower growth or viral results.
- Suggestions to buy followers or use engagement pods.
- No understanding of ad disclosure or data protection.
- Inability to explain results beyond likes and follower counts.
- Dismissive attitudes towards customer complaints.
Any one of these suggests a candidate who may create risk for your brand.
Freelance or permanent
Some organisations start with a freelancer to test what they need before hiring permanently. Freelancers bring flexibility and specialist skills; permanent staff bring continuity and deeper brand knowledge. The Academy's guide to the freelance social media manager explains how freelance arrangements usually work.
Checking knowledge is current
Platform knowledge goes out of date quickly. Ask about recent changes they have adapted to, and how they keep up. Candidates who rely on memory of how things worked a few years ago may struggle. The Academy's guide to how to keep up with social media changes describes good habits.
Certificates and qualifications
There is no single required qualification for social media managers. Certificates can show commitment to learning, but look at what they cover and whether they are current. Academy certificates include a verify page, so employers can check them; they are the Academy's own certificates, not a regulated qualification.
Onboarding
A good start sets the tone. Give the new manager access to accounts, brand guidelines, past results, key contacts and an early set of priorities. Plan a 90-day review. The Academy's guide to onboarding a social media manager provides a checklist.
Supporting growth after hiring
The best hires keep learning. Offer development time, a training budget and access to up-to-date learning. A personalised path that skips what they already know respects their experience while filling gaps. The Academy's free assessment is a quick way to see where a new hire is strongest.
