UK consumer law, strengthened by the DMCC Act, bans concealed incentivised reviews. The key word is concealed. An incentive that is open, applies to any honest review and is allowed by the platform where the review is posted can be acceptable. An incentive that is hidden or only rewards praise is not. The Academy's glossary explains the DMCC Act.
The conditions
| Condition | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Disclosed | Readers must know the reviewer was rewarded |
| Not conditional on positivity | Rewarding only good reviews distorts ratings |
| Offered to all customers | Selective offers can skew results |
| Allowed by the platform | Many platforms ban incentives entirely |
| Honest reviews only | No guidance on what to say |
Platform rules often go further
Several major review platforms prohibit incentivised reviews altogether, regardless of disclosure. Google's policies, for example, do not allow businesses to offer incentives for reviews, and marketplaces such as Amazon have strict rules. Breaking platform rules can lead to reviews being removed or penalties on your listing. Check each platform's current policy before offering anything.
Social media comments and posts
Asking followers to comment or post about you in exchange for a discount creates incentivised content. If the posts act as reviews or recommendations, the incentive should be clear. Creator content paid with products or discounts is advertising and needs labelling. The Academy's guide to ASA influencer rules explains this.
Safer alternatives
- Ask without incentives: a polite request at the right time works well.
- Make it easy: direct links, QR codes and short instructions.
- Thank everyone: thank all reviewers publicly, positive or negative.
- Reward feedback privately: offer a discount for completing a private survey, not a public review.
- Improve the experience: better service generates more reviews naturally.
Prize draws for reviews
Entering reviewers into a prize draw is still an incentive. It must be disclosed, open to all reviewers regardless of rating and allowed by the platform. Prize draws also need fair terms. The Academy's guide to social media competition rules covers terms.
Wording examples
Problematic: Leave us a five-star review and get 10 percent off your next order.
Better, where the platform allows incentives: We would love your honest feedback. Everyone who leaves a review, good or bad, gets 10 percent off their next order. Please mention in your review that you received this offer.
Safest for most platforms: We would love your honest feedback. Here is the link to leave a review.
Testimonials in your own marketing
If you use reviews from customers who received incentives in social posts or ads, disclose the incentive or choose reviews from customers who were not rewarded. The Academy's guide to fake reviews law explains duties for publishing reviews.
Messaging customers
Review requests sent by email or text are marketing communications in some cases and must follow electronic marketing rules. Transactional messages, such as order confirmations, can usually include a review request without marketing consent, but promotional content changes that. WhatsApp broadcast lists only reach people who have saved your number, with up to 256 recipients per list (recipients must have saved your number)✓, which limits unsolicited messaging there. The Academy's guide on whether you can send marketing DMs covers messaging rules.
Why honesty pays
Customers increasingly distrust perfect ratings. A mix of reviews with thoughtful responses from the business builds more trust than a wall of five stars. Incentive schemes that distort ratings risk platform penalties and regulatory action for little long-term gain.
Incentives for creators and reviewers
Sending free products to creators or reviewers in exchange for reviews is an incentive too. Reviews written after receiving free products should make that clear, and creators posting about gifted products should disclose the gift. If the brand requires or controls the review, it is advertising. The Academy's guide to gifted product disclosure explains the labels.
Record what you offer
Keep a note of any review incentive, when it ran and the wording used.
Timing review requests
The best time to ask for a review is soon after a positive moment: a delivery that arrived on time, a completed service or a happy comment on social media. A short, friendly request at that moment often works better than any incentive. Follow up once if needed, but avoid repeated reminders that feel like pressure.
Responding to every review
Responding to reviews encourages more people to leave them, because customers see that the business reads and values feedback. Thank positive reviewers by name, respond calmly to criticism and explain what you have changed. The Academy's guide on how to respond to reviews has examples.
A worked example
A beauty salon offers a free treatment for every five-star Google review. After learning the rules, it stops the offer, which breached both consumer law and Google's policies. Instead, it sends every client a short message after appointments with a direct review link and replies to every review. Review numbers dip briefly, then grow steadily with a more credible mix of ratings.
Common mistakes
- Rewarding only positive reviews.
- Not disclosing incentives.
- Ignoring platform bans on incentives.
- Asking staff or friends to review.
- Using incentivised reviews in ads without disclosure.
Learning the rules
The Academy's legal and ethical module in the third level covers reviews, incentives and consumer law. Content on this page is general information, not legal advice. The free assessment shows where you would start.
