A fake review is one that claims to be based on a genuine experience of a product or business when it is not, or that hides who wrote it or why. The rules cover reviews anywhere consumers might rely on them: review sites, Google, marketplaces, app stores, social media comments and testimonials in ads. The Academy's glossary explains the DMCC Act and the CMA.
Banned practices
| Practice | Example |
|---|---|
| Writing fake reviews | Staff posting reviews pretending to be customers |
| Commissioning fake reviews | Paying a service to post positive reviews |
| Concealed incentivised reviews | Rewarding reviews without disclosing it |
| Misleading presentation | Hiding negative reviews or merging reviews across different products misleadingly |
| Facilitating fake reviews | Offering or advertising fake review services |
Incentivised reviews
Offering an incentive, such as a discount, prize draw entry or free product, in exchange for a review is not automatically banned, but the incentive must be disclosed and must not depend on the review being positive. Rewarding only five-star reviews is a clear problem. The Academy's guide on whether you can offer discounts for reviews goes into detail.
Staff, friends and family
Reviews from employees, family members or friends of the owner can mislead because readers assume independence. Avoid asking them to review your business; if they do, the connection should be clear.
Review gating
Review gating means asking customers how happy they are and only inviting satisfied ones to leave public reviews. It can present a misleading picture and may breach rules on how reviews are collected and presented. Invite all customers equally.
Duties for businesses that publish reviews
Businesses that publish reviews, including on their own websites or social channels, should take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent and remove fake reviews and to avoid presenting reviews misleadingly. That might include:
- A clear review policy.
- Checks for suspicious patterns.
- Processes to investigate and remove fakes.
- Disclosure of incentives.
- Showing negative as well as positive reviews.
Social media specifics
- Comments: planting fake comments under your posts, or using fake accounts to praise your products, can count as fake reviews.
- Testimonials in ads: must be genuine, from real customers, with evidence held.
- Creator content: paid creator reviews must be labelled as ads.
- Buying engagement: bought likes or followers can mislead about popularity.
Recommendations and ratings
Facebook Page recommendations, Google ratings and marketplace stars are all reviews for these purposes. The Academy's guide to Facebook reviews for business covers that platform, and the guide on how to respond to reviews covers handling feedback.
Responding to fake negative reviews
Competitors or malicious accounts sometimes post fake negative reviews. Report them to the platform with evidence, respond calmly and factually in public and avoid accusations you cannot prove. The Academy's glossary explains defamation, which may be relevant in serious cases.
Enforcement
The CMA can investigate and fine businesses directly, with penalties linked to turnover. It has previously secured commitments from major platforms to tackle fake reviews and has published guidance for businesses. Trading Standards also enforces consumer law locally.
Getting genuine reviews
Ask every customer, make it easy with a direct link, time requests soon after a good experience and respond to reviews to show you value them. Genuine reviews grow steadily and are far more convincing than a sudden burst of five stars. Platforms such as Reddit also matter for reputation, since Reddit threads rank prominently in Google results — a discoverability channel beyond the platform itself✓, so genuine customer discussions can surface in search.
Using reviews in marketing
Quoting reviews in social posts and ads is fine if they are genuine, representative and not edited to change their meaning. Keep the original review and permission where needed. Do not present a single glowing review as typical if most are mixed.
Spotting fake reviews on your own pages
Signs of fake reviews include bursts of similar reviews in a short period, accounts with no other activity, generic wording that could apply to any business and reviews mentioning products you do not sell. Check your pages regularly, report suspicious reviews to the platform and keep notes of what you found and did. Those records help show that you took reasonable steps.
Removing reviews you dislike
Businesses should not remove or hide genuine negative reviews just because they are unfavourable. Removing fakes and abusive content is fine; filtering out honest criticism presents a misleading picture.
Agencies and reputation services
Some agencies and online services offer to boost ratings. Be cautious: services that write reviews, use networks of accounts or promise particular star ratings can put your business in breach. Ask exactly how any reputation service collects reviews before signing up, and get assurances in writing.
A worked example
A restaurant's marketing agency suggests posting reviews from staff accounts to improve its rating. The owner refuses, removes reviews from staff relatives and introduces QR codes on receipts inviting every diner to leave an honest review. Ratings dip slightly at first, then rise steadily as genuine reviews accumulate, and the restaurant replies to every review.
Common mistakes
- Staff or family reviews presented as customers.
- Rewarding only positive reviews.
- Review gating.
- Hiding negative reviews.
- Buying engagement or reviews.
Learning the rules
The Academy's legal and ethical module in the third level covers reviews, consumer law and the DMCC Act, and the community management module covers handling feedback. Content on this page is general information, not legal advice. The free assessment shows where you would start.
