There is no universally right answer. The best choice depends on budget, how much content you need, how specialised the work is, how quickly you need to respond and how much management time you can give. Thinking through each factor makes the decision clearer.
The options
- In house: a member of staff, full or part time, runs social media.
- Agency: an external company manages some or all of the work.
- Freelancer: an independent specialist works on a contract.
- Hybrid: in-house staff handle daily activity while an agency or freelancer handles strategy, paid social or production.
Side-by-side comparison
| Factor | In house | Agency |
|---|---|---|
| Knowledge of the business | Deep, day to day | Built over time through briefings |
| Speed of response | Immediate | Depends on contract and process |
| Range of skills | Limited to the person or team | Strategists, designers, editors, paid specialists |
| Cost structure | Salary, training, tools | Monthly retainer or project fees |
| Management time | Line management and development | Briefing, approvals and account reviews |
| Fresh perspective | Can become inward-looking | Ideas from other sectors and clients |
| Continuity risk | Depends on one person staying | Account teams can change |
| Scaling up | Hiring takes months | Can add resource quickly |
When in house works best
- Content relies on daily access to people, products or premises.
- Customer messages need fast, knowledgeable replies.
- The brand voice is distinctive and hard to brief.
- Volume is steady and predictable.
- You can invest in training and development.
When an agency works best
- You need specialist skills, such as paid social or video production, without hiring full time.
- Activity is campaign-based with peaks and troughs.
- You want a fresh outside perspective.
- Nobody in the business has time to manage social media day to day.
- You need to scale quickly.
Hybrid models
Many businesses combine the two. A common approach is an in-house coordinator who posts, replies and captures everyday content, supported by an agency for strategy, paid campaigns and larger productions. Hybrids work well when roles are clearly defined and both sides share one plan and one calendar.
Cost considerations
Compare the full cost of each option. In house includes salary, employer costs, equipment, software, training and management time. Agencies charge retainers or project fees, and costs rise as scope grows. Include the cost of any learning curve, because a new person or agency takes time to understand the business. The Academy's guide to a social media budget breaks down costs.
Skills and training
An in-house person needs a wide range of skills: writing, photography, video, community management, analytics and often paid social. Few people excel at all of them at once. Training closes gaps, and platforms change so often that skills need regular refreshing. The Academy checks platform facts weekly, publishes a public changelog and lets learners test out of modules they already know, which suits busy in-house marketers.
Control and approvals
In-house teams usually move faster because approvals are informal. Agencies need clear approval processes, which slows things down but can improve quality and compliance. Agree response times in any agency contract, especially for comments and messages.
Responding to platform change
Platforms change features and ranking regularly. Agencies see changes across many accounts and may spot shifts sooner. In-house teams know their own audience better. Either way, someone needs to keep up; for example, LinkedIn's documented ranking signals are early comments and dwell time, relevance to professional interests, creator-audience relationship; links often reduce reach✓, and knowing that shapes how content is planned.
Making the decision
- List the work needed each month: posts, replies, video, ads, reports.
- Estimate the hours and skills each task requires.
- Cost the in-house, agency and hybrid options fully.
- Consider speed, control and risk for your business.
- Start with a trial period or a defined project where possible.
Questions to ask an agency
- Who will work on our account day to day?
- What experience do you have in our sector?
- How will you learn our business and voice?
- What are response times for comments and messages?
- How will you report results, and against which goals?
- Who owns the accounts, logins and content?
Ownership matters: make sure the business always owns its social accounts and has admin access, whoever manages them. The Academy's guide on how to manage a social media agency covers working together well.
A worked example
A regional estate agency has one marketing assistant posting listings and replying to messages. Results are steady but video quality is low and paid campaigns are inconsistent. The business keeps the assistant for daily posting and replies, and hires an agency on a monthly retainer for paid social and a quarterly video shoot. The assistant trains in short-form video basics to film everyday content. Within six months, enquiries from paid social rise while costs stay predictable.
Freelancers as a middle option
A freelancer can offer specialist skills at lower cost than an agency, with more flexibility than a hire. The trade-off is capacity and cover: one person can fall ill or take on other clients. Agree availability and response times clearly.
Common mistakes
- Comparing an agency retainer with a salary alone, ignoring other costs.
- Hiring an agency without clear goals or a brief.
- Expecting one in-house person to master every skill.
- Letting an agency own logins or accounts.
- No clear division of roles in a hybrid model.
Learning to lead social media
The Academy's team and governance module in the leader level covers structuring social media teams, working with agencies and approvals. The free assessment shows where you would start, and in-house marketers can test out of modules they already know.
